Comparison

UE 5.8 built-in toon shader vs post-process toon: what each one does

Unreal Engine 5.8 added toon shading inside Substrate, and it stylizes one material at a time. A post-process toon shader restyles the whole finished frame without touching any material. They solve different problems: the first is for art you are building, the second is for a scene that already exists.

By RafaSC, 3D and technical artist · Updated · 6 min read

Toon Studio: a tea house switching between toon styles

I sell a post-process toon pack, so read this as one side of the table. What I say about the built-in shader comes from Epic's release notes and the write-ups linked at the end, not from my own production tests. What I say about the post-process side is measured on my own pack.

The short version

Built-in toon shading (Substrate, UE 5.8)Post-process toon shader
What it changesOne material at a timeThe whole frame
Where it runsIn the material and the lightingAfter the scene is rendered, reading the G-Buffer
SetupYou author or convert materialsOne actor or one post-process material
OutlinesNot part of it: edge detection still lives in postUsually included
Bought assetsEach material has to be changedWork as they are
RendererSubstrateDeferred renderer
PricePart of the engineDepends on the pack

What the built-in toon shader is

It is a way to shade a surface in flat bands as part of how that material answers to real lights. The banding follows actual light direction and shadowing per material, which is something a screen-space effect cannot do exactly. According to the StraySpark write-up, before 5.8 this kind of shading needed a custom shading model, which meant maintaining an engine fork.

It is also new. One write-up from July 2026 calls it a "version-one feature" and warns to expect rough edges with translucency, some light types and unusual Substrate stacks. And it only shades surfaces: for ink lines you still need a post-process edge pass or inverted-hull meshes.

What a post-process toon shader is

It never sees your materials. It reads the buffers of the finished frame (normals, depth, base colour) and redraws the light as flat tones, then adds lines where depth and normals change. That is why it can restyle a level full of assets you did not make.

A tea house scene: left as built, right with a manga post-process look applied
Same meshes, materials and lights. One actor dropped in the level.

The price is that it is a screen-space effect. It needs the deferred renderer, because the Forward renderer does not expose the G-Buffer to post process. And on photoreal assets the change is subtler: it is made for stylized and low-poly scenes.

In my own pack the tone bands follow your Directional Light, lines and tones are computed before TSR/TAA so nothing flashes when the camera moves, and emissive and unlit materials are kept as they are.

A cube and four spheres with 3-tone toon shading: deep shadow, flat shadow band, light spot that follows the sun and a thin ink outline
Three flat tones, a light spot that follows the sun and an ink line.

When to use which

  • You are authoring characters or hero props and want exact control of each surface: the built-in shader fits, because the look is part of the material.
  • You have a level that already exists, with bought or mixed assets: a post process changes all of it at once.
  • You want to switch style during the game (flashback, dream sequence, photo mode): a post process can blend between looks at runtime.
  • You want outlines: you need a post-process pass either way.
  • You target the Forward renderer: a G-Buffer post process cannot work there.

Can you use both?

In principle they do different jobs, and an outline-only post process draws a line over art it does not touch. I have not tested my pack on materials that use the built-in toon shading, so I will not promise a result. What the listing states: Custom Toon Shaders Studio works with Lumen, TSR, Nanite and Substrate on UE 5.8.

Nine versions of the same tea house: Toon, Painted Brush, Ghibli, Watercolor, Neon, Moebius, Sumi-e, Sketch and Pixel
Nine of the thirteen looks on the same scene.

If you want to try the post-process side without paying, Toon Studio Lite is free and has three looks.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Does Unreal Engine 5.8 have a built-in toon shader?

Yes. UE 5.8 added toon shading inside Substrate. It works per material, as part of how that material responds to lights.

Does the built-in UE 5.8 toon shader draw outlines?

No. According to the write-ups available, it handles surface shading and edge detection still lives in post process, or you use inverted-hull meshes.

Which is better for a level made of bought assets?

A post-process toon shader, because it restyles the finished frame and does not need you to change each material.

Does Custom Toon Shaders Studio work with Substrate?

Yes. It works with Lumen, TSR, Nanite and Substrate on Unreal Engine 5.8. It has not been tested on materials that use the built-in toon shading.

Related guides

UE 5.8 Toon Shader vs Post-Process Toon: Which One?: summary image for Pinterest

Save this guide for later. Product used on this page: Custom Toon Shaders Studio.